Skip to the bar list
Café 59

Open now until 10 PM

At the Bar

Full bar, every day 11 to 10 Happy hour Mon to Thu 2 to 6

Sixteen house cocktails, two mocktails, wine by the glass and bottle, local craft and sour drafts, and a non-alcoholic list that is not an afterthought.

Call (716) 883-1880

Cocktails

Sixteen house originals. Ask the bartender what is shaking this week.

  • Campground

    Bourbon, Ramazzotti amaro, rhubarb, Islay Scotch, Dr Pepper syrup, orange

    $14.00
  • Cat's Pajamas

    Gin, elderflower, Campari, grapefruit, lavender

    $13.00
  • Chip off the old Block

    Bourbon, amaretto, orange, bitters, cherry, lemon

    $14.00
  • Corduroy Bear

    Rye whiskey, Cardamaro, Montenegro amaro, bitters

    $12.00
  • Dirty, Dirty Chai

    Vodka, chai, coffee, cream, nutmeg

    $13.00
  • Espress Yourself

    Rum, coffee liqueur, cold brew, orgeat, simple

    $14.00
  • Fiery Dove

    Chili crisp, tequila, grapefruit, lime, soda

    $13.00
  • Golden Dai-Curry

    Aged rum, rhum agricole, saffron, lemon, ginger, vanilla, cinnamon, curry

    $13.00
  • Jiminy Cricket

    Cucumber vodka, lime, elderflower, aloe, simple

    $14.00
  • Jubilee

    Reposado tequila, pineapple, lime, hibiscus-champagne syrup

    $13.00
  • Marg Mcgrath

    Tequila, strawberry, banana, lime, orange

    $13.00
  • Penicillin

    Blended Scotch, ginger, honey, lemon, Islay Scotch

    $16.00
  • Pinky Swear

    Bourbon, elderflower, lemon, cherry, champagne

    $13.00
  • Red Velvet

    White rum, red velvet, lemon, vanilla, cacao, simple, aquafaba

    $12.00
  • Royal Brumble

    Empress gin, blackberry, vanilla, honey, lemon

    $14.00
  • Sotol Recall

    Sotol, mezcal, Campari, amaro, cinnamon, grapefruit

    $15.00

Mocktails

  • The Professor

    N/A mezcal, lime, cinnamon, orgeat, plum, cardamom

    $10.00
  • FAR TOOLONG

    N/A rum, spiced syrup, oolong, cardamom, hot water

    $10.00

Wine

By the glass or the bottle. Tax included.

  • Souverain Cabernet Sauvignon

    California

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Darkhorse Pinot Noir

    California

    Glass
    $10.75
    Bottle
    $37.50
  • Tutto Mio Sweet Red

    Italy

    Glass
    $11.50
    Bottle
    $40.25
  • Natura Malbec

    Chile

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Prophecy Rosé

    California

    Glass
    $10.25
    Bottle
    $31.00
  • Folonari Pinot Grigio

    Italy

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Souverain Chardonnay

    California

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Souverain Sauvignon Blanc

    California

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Fetzer Riesling

    California

    Glass
    $9.75
    Bottle
    $34.50
  • Charles de Fère Brut

    France, sparkling

    Glass
    $9.50
    Bottle
    $33.75

Beer

Local first, sours always. Strengths as listed by the brewery.

Lagers and pilsners

  • Labatt Blue, Blue Light

    5% and 4%

    $4.50
  • Narragansett

    5%

    $4.50
  • Miller High Life

    4.6%

    $4.50
  • Flying Bison, Rusty Chain

    Vienna lager, 5.2%

    $6.00
  • Modelo Especial

    4.4%

    $6.50
  • Negra Modelo

    5.4%

    $6.50
  • Genny Cream Ale

    5.1%

    $4.00
  • Thin Man, Mafia Light

    Light lager, 3.5%

    $5.25

IPAs

  • Founders, All Day IPA

    Session IPA, 4.7%

    $7.00
  • Stone, Delicious

    Citrus IPA, 7.7%

    $8.00
  • Big Ditch, Hayburner

    American IPA, 7%

    $8.00
  • Sloop, Juice Bomb

    Hazy NE IPA, 6.5%

    $8.50
  • Toppling Goliath, Cyber Sue

    American IPA, 7.2%

    $8.25
  • Modist, Teal Label

    West Coast IPA, 6.3%

    $7.25

Sours

  • Prairie Artisan, Slush

    Sour ale with strawberry, raspberry, lemon and lime, 6.1%

    $11.75
  • Westbrook, Orange Hibiscus Gose

    4%

    $8.50
  • Evil Twin, Grape Soda Sour

    5%

    $10.75
  • Urban Artifact, Teak

    Pineapple, guava and key lime sour, 7.2%

    $8.75
  • Urban Artifact, Kwen

    Blueberry and grape sour, 7.2%

    $8.00
  • Urban Artifact, Capy Snacks

    Black raspberry sour, 5%

    $6.50

Dark beers

  • Community Beer Works, The Whale

    American brown ale, 5.9%

    $7.50
  • Left Hand, Nitro Milk Stout

    6%

    $8.50
  • Great Lakes, Edmund Fitzgerald

    Robust porter, 6%

    $7.00

Belgians, saisons, wheats

  • Une Année, Twist of Wit

    Belgian wheat with orange and coriander, 4.5%

    $10.75
  • Unibroue, La Fin du Monde

    Belgian tripel blonde, 9%

    $12.50
  • Kronenbourg Blanc

    French witbier, 5%

    $8.00
  • 21st Amendment, Hell or High Watermelon

    Watermelon wheat, 4.9%

    $6.50

Ciders, meads, kombucha

  • B Nektar, Punk Lemonade

    Raspberry lemonade mead, 6.3%

    $12.50
  • Boochcraft

    Ginger lime hard kombucha, 7%

    $9.00
  • Brooklyn Cider House, Cider Rosé

    Off-dry cider with sour cherry, wild raspberry and rose petals, 5.8%

    $9.75
  • Brooklyn Cider House, Kinda Dry

    Off-dry cider, 5.5%

    Price at the bar

Seltzers and canned cocktails

  • High Noon, Sun Sips

    Hard seltzer: watermelon, pineapple, black cherry, 4.5%

    $8.50
  • Surfside

    Green tea, strawberry lemonade, 4.5%

    $9.00

Without alcohol

  • Athletic, Upside Dawn

    Non-alcoholic golden ale, under 0.5%

    $6.50
  • Lagunitas, IPNA

    Non-alcoholic IPA, under 0.5%

    $6.00
  • Untitled Art, flvr!

    Mango dragonfruit non-alcoholic sour, under 0.5%

    $10.00
  • Hop Water For the World

    Citra, Mosaic and El Dorado hopped water

    $6.50
  • Casamara Club, Alta

    Negroni-style soda

    $9.00
  • IBC Root Beer

    $4.00
  • Fever Tree Ginger Beer

    $3.50
  • Dr. Pepper

    $3.50

Happy hour

Monday to Thursday, 2 to 6 PM, dine-in only

  • Café Smash Burger

    With potato wedges. Make it a double for 8 more.

    $10
  • Chicken Finger Sliders

    Three, any sauce, with wedges

    $10
  • Polenta Wings

    Single 10, double 18

    $10
  • Wedge Plates

    Sweet and smokey, salt and vinegar, Cajun, or original

    $5
  • House Daiquiri

    $8
  • Tito's Martini

    $8
  • House Manhattan or Old Fashioned

    $8

Happy hour as posted November 2025. Ask the bar if it is on today.

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nuts, sesame seeds, gluten or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.